Documents for a Bar Complaint against Paul Staunton Kibel are at the bottom of this page.
Paul is related to the Water and Power Law Group PC and he is faculty at Golden Gate University and the Berkley School of Law.
While you are free to scroll to the bottom to get what you think you might want to read first, I'd HIGHLY SUGGEST you read your way to the bottom. Do as you wish.
On May 15, 2021 we closed escrow on a deal fueled by Broker and Seller Fraud. It included an RPA (Residential Purchase Agreement) straight out of Babylon that likely is NOT supported for use by CA Code 1102 and looks like it came from a Babylonian Board Game designed to teach Legal Theory.
Thankfully, it appears enough of the threads of CA 1102 can be combined with RPA 13B and 13D to default the contract, BUT it's clear they were trying to nibble into all of that too. They just hadn't gotten far enough in to cut off the connections completely.
By January 2022 we had done all our invasive inspections. We had been forced to make major plumbing upgrades just to live in a home that did not actually have a functional and reliable sewage system, contrary to disclosures and claims made by Seller, when questioned.
By that time, rainy season had commenced. With that, we were able to document the flooding problems that were suggested by the Neighbor and Sellers Agent, but emphatically denied by the Seller, or whoever was creating his disclosure statements.
It was apparent from dialogue with neighbors, the sellers agent, and whoever was writing things for the seller that the seller seemed to live paycheck to paycheck without sound money management or home organization skills. He also wasn't real estate saavy.
What we did NOT know with any level of confidence was the level with which he was involved in his very own real estate transaction.
For all we knew, the Sellers Agent was sending the digital signature requests to an email address he himself controlled. He was signing everything for the seller, possibly. It really was, or could have been that bad. This digital signature system is "horse sh-t" on steroids. Convenient, but impossible to use in courts.
There were numerous flags and concerns indicating that or something comparably vague was transpiring. Maybe his wife or children were filling things in for him for convenience, mental diminishment or other reasons.
On January 17, 2021, I sent an email with a 20+ page pdf to the seller to attempt to open a direct dialogue with him. The goal was to get some level of insight as to his awareness of what transpired , to see if he could communicate, and to see how he might do that without an Agent involved.
Best case for us? He admitted he had no idea what was going on, and he was lead to do everything by the Agent/Broker.
Second Best? It might have been that we found out he was incompetent or incapacitated, thus putting a lot more blame on the broker for steering the entire thing.
He did eventually acknowledge email receipt. Unfortunately, he indicated he'd have an Attorney reach out, thus cover from another Agent was incoming.
The Attorney who reached out was Paul Staunton Kibel. Lead Counsel for the Water and Power Law Group PC. A Law Firm that specializes in National (and maybe international) water rights.
According to their website,
"[Paul] is a tenured Professor at Golden Gate University where he teaches Water Law and California Environmental and Natural Resources Law. "
"[Paul] is also a Visiting Professor in Water Law at Boalt Hall Law School, University of California at Berkeley. "
Why is this guy stepping into a Real Estate Transaction Dispute in Monterey County?
As you'll see by his use of the term "sale" he doesn't know real estate law. As you'll also see, on an Attorney inversion scale for written documentation, he actually ranks quite low in technique.
Did they come up short on billing for the month? Do they know each other through "Church"? Is there a connection in the Berkley Area that put them together?
By the time Kibel stuck his neck into our transaction, we had been through one of the most horrific runs of Professional Malfeasance I could have imagined. The last thing I needed was an Environmental Law Attorney clouding the view of the Seller that I needed to craft a strategy for some personal rectification on the low end, and all out Real Estate Brokerage Destruction on the high end.
Before getting to Kibel, let me give you glimpse at the US Professional world as Ive experirenced it in the past few years...
CPA - My CPA of 20 years got knocked off his rocker by COVID. He acted illogically during some of my financing applications and I gave him notice of relationship termination. He failed to deliver documents due to me per his professional code. A Claim was filed with the MD DLLR. They acted obtuse and covered for him, with the support of the Atty Generals office of MD. That's all been covered in websites and a Bar Complaint against two Attorney Generals of MD. Did you know the MD Bar Complaint process has no public reporting requirements nor is it subject to FOIA? My complaint with the AICPA was filed in December 2021, and as of this writing in March 2023, 15 months later, it's still pending.
Appraiser - We had an appraiser for a refinance in Baltimore claim the home next to my own, which was one I had built as a twin and just sold for 450,000 was an 'outlier sale' and not available for use, even though that was the second transfer for it in the past three years with the prior being at 423,000. There was also a sale on the block for a new construction infill town home comparable in size in the $575,000 range. However, in stupifying fashion, instead of moving the "outlier" to the 4,5 or 6 position, he left it in 1st position and just ignored it. Thus he used 2 properties to comp my property and those he used violated characteristics that he claimed he couldn't use in others. A complaint was filed with massive documentation around December 2021 as well. Apparenlty it's been adjudicated. I got no formal notice. I'm trying to follow up now. The indiation was he was going to lose his ability to do appraisals for Federal Loans. That's basically a business wipe out. The qusetion though is simple. Why should he be allowed to continue to do private appraisals at all? The breach was awful The system only "kind of worked".
Two Mortgage Lenders - I found a guy in Florida who tried to do a refinance for me in Maryland without a Maryland License. He's with a national company that seemed to have picked up some of the Countrywide executives who fueled the 2008 subprime crisis from Southern CA. New company, old people. I found a woman California who tried to upsell me a higher rate loan claiming my partners standard w2 income didn't qualify for 80% of what it did at face value with a 5 second calculation. She was the recommended lender in a Coldwell Banker office in Morgan Hill, a silicon valley outpost. She had decades of experience. Neither of these have been formally reported yet, and the later is "gypsy in the face" type wrong.
Other Mortgage Lenders - Everyone has gone to desktop underwriting. Few wanted to take the time to help me as a self employed person. Those that did had no proper spreadsheets or tools to get the math right. Literally.
This is "just recently" and some other stuff has transpired since then.
Title Company in Washington DC / Baltimore Area - I caught a Title Company in the Washington DC area who had setup a shell title company to do work for French Real Estate broker. That title company was manipulating money and deposits and tax withholdings with a flare of gypsism that was startling, if you know what it looks like.
Veterinarians without Training and International Veterinarians incoming? - I've discovered new Veterinarians don't know what a $50 hair mineral analysis test is and the older ones who do, won't talk to you about it because they know they might be targeted by the Vaccine or Pet Food companies for death (literally). My Cat, Mr. Frisco suffered from over 50 seizures in a 15 month period before i could hear him say, "Get my fur tested", which I did. That's when I found out he'd be declared Hazzardous Waste for Mercury and Aluminum Toxicity. The "approved" Fish Food I was feeding him was toxic. The company making it played gypsy games in wirting when I inquired. The Food oversight board responsible for the produce I bought is using a law firm that is also representing the food manufacturers the oversight company is meant to regulate. I've also notice an influx of seemingly French and European professionals in two of the local Vet offices. One is a National Franchise. The other is a new local office with a part time Vet cycling through
Pardon my "French". This shit's BROKE. The people who have contributed the most to bringing this country to it's knees since 9/11 and covering it all up are ATTORNEYS in every walk of life and some of them seem to have some really inverted things in common too.
All of you feel you are worth so much per hour you can only serve those higher up the chain to nowhere, and all the "confidentiality bullshit" has destroyed this country tip to tail.
Congratulations. You've won "something" I would never want to lay claim to.
This isn't a "Jewish Problem" but to some without discernment it might look that way on the surface...
The Seller in my Transaction was Micah Forstein. The Sellers Agent in my Transaction was Kent Weinstein. They seemingly know each other from the Unitarian Universalist Church of Monterey County. (not a Jewish Synagogue in the formal and righteous sense. ) The two "pastors" of this Monterey Church studied "something" in the UC Berkley area that has no religious text and seems to claim it's just about learning ethics and morals. One of them is an Attorney. Can you imagine trying to get your moral and ethical teachings from an Attorney? The Church itself looks very clearly like a political action committee for all things Democratic leaning and progressive that ultimate benefit the mining families of the world, who typically run through French speaking countries.
I'm sorry if this is overstepping my bounds, but this does NOT appear to be a "Jewish" problem as is often blamed. It does, however, feel familiar to another historical situation that stimulated a rise in various things in Europe in the 1920s that lead to what people thought was a problem that had very different roots in history. And that's only one of "how many" situations like it that have played out in the past few 1000 years?
This is all "Just My Opinion." You are free to have your own. I'm a practicing magician who uses moon cycles, curses and cats to navigate the world. I know that's very familiar to some of you, fascinatingly bizarre to others, it scares off some, terrifies others, and the rest will NEVER read this. This place is in gross disarray. It needs to be fixed, and it starts with you.
CA Supreme Court Appeal of Bar Complaint Adjudication Process for Attorney Paul Kibel
Doc 0 - Supreme Court Appeal Document
Exhibits - Group A ( table of contents || spacer sheets )
A1 - Email from Kibel - States all dialogue was subject to full Confidentiality per statute when no such statutes exist
A2 - Letter from Kibel - Kibel made false representations of As Is Sales that contradict statutes and Case precedents. Kibel made false statements about representation statements and requirements. Kibel made false statement of fact about mediation clause (multiple times)
A3 - Email from Kibel’s Malpractice Attorney - She refers to his rights to make fraudulent statements prior to formal litigation as being part of his rights to free speech. She threatens anti-SLAPP lawsuit if he is sued
A4 - Flowcharts - Flowcharts the reveal the full scope of the individual transaction fraud , which is a lead in to the flow charts that reveal the full scope of the Legal Lobby involvement in creation of fraudulent contract documents since 1985.
A5 - Adjudication Letter #1 from CA Bar - Attorney Dorian inverted our complaint and ignored the most relevant frauds
A6 - Adjudication Letter #2 from CA Bar - Refusal to take any action in the fact of patently false and fraudulent misrepresentation of statute and law used for intimidation and coercion
A7 - Appeal to the CRU unit - This is the appeal document to the Complaint Review Unit. This summarizes the key parts of the original complaint and points out Attorney Dorians frauds.
A8 - Appeal to the CRU unit - supplement - Supplement sent when Kibel and his firm sought mal-practice protection
Service Reference
Short of Disbarment for Kibel and Dorian,
this gets Appealed to the CA Supreme Court.
Nobody has a position to watch these watchers anymore,
and they are not watching out for the rest of us.
No other way to shed light in the malfeasance at the CA Bar.